Showing posts with label novice. Show all posts
Showing posts with label novice. Show all posts

Monday, October 5, 2026

Dear Latin Novella Authors

Previously I had written a blog post to Novice-Level novella authors, praising them for why I felt successful reading their novice low/mid Spanish novellas. This one is now directed to Latin novella authors.

Dear Latin Novella Authors,

10 years have passed since the first Latin novellas Brando Brown Canem Vult and Pluto: Fabula Amoris came out. Since 2016, a great number of Latin novellas have since been published - I love that finally Latin novellas are on the scene! Thank you for writing these much needed readings which greatly support the acquisition of the Latin language. Krashen writes:

“More speaking or writing does not result in more language or literacy development, but more reading does.”

However, Latin authors, I have one request: we need more Latin novellas truly written for emerging/novice low level readers. We are leaving out a huge portion of our Latin student population. While many Latin teachers may feel that we need more upper-level novellas, hear me out.

My foundational argument is this: although our beginning Latin 1 students may be advanced readers of English, they are only emerging readers of Latin (not even novice yet). A huge false assumption which we Latin teachers have is that when we begin to introduce readings to our Latin 1 students at the beginning of first semester, our students should be able to read them. The reality, however, is:

  1. many of our students do NOT possess a high reading level when they come to our Latin 1 classes due to having come through the balanced literacy approach and never actually learning to read or due to not being a native speaker of English.
  2. one's reading level in one's primary reading language does NOT transfer immediately to reading in another language. It is not a 1:1 exchange. This includes the ability to decode words when reading. To say that a student who can read X number of words/minute in English should then be able to read that same number of words/minute in Latin is faulty. In the Winter 2026 edition of The Language Educator (ACTFL's magazine), in its article, "Leveraging the Science of Reading Research for Multilingual Success in Dual Language Immersion Programs," Budke and Showers note that we must "acknowledge that transfer between foundational skills in English and the partner language is not automatic and many phonemes and graphemes require explicit instruction."
In the beginning, level 1 students are dealing with a lot at once when reading Latin: they are still familiarizing themselves with how the Latin language appears as a written language, the sounds which the letters represent, the inflected nature of the language, that the verb usually appears at the end of the sentence, and that these words have a meaning attached to them.

In addition, what we think is level-appropriate readings for emerging/novice-level readers is actually not in reality. Latin textbooks have "told" us what are "level-appropriate" readings for Latin 1, but Latin 1 textbook readings are not aligned with any true acquisition theory but rather with a race to get students to translate classical literature by the 3rd year. 

Aspects of emerging/novice-low target language readings are:
  • short sentences, with each primarily focusing on one idea
  • predictable sentence patterns
  • limited vocabulary AND grammatical structures (now is not the time to introduce "shelter vocabulary but not grammar")
  • repeated use of sentences
  • sentences are not written as paragraphs but rather as individual lines
  • high usage of English cognates and proper nouns so that readers can then focus on the target language words
  • pictures to aid students in their comprehension (I do feel a bit uneasy with this though due to how much "look at the pictures" played a role in balanced literacy and how students struggled to read when the pictures disappeared)
How often do we find our students never developing their Latin reading skills, because they are rather focusing their attention on stopping at every single word in a sentence to decode it? That does not develop reading.

Some of you may be saying, "Well, my Latin 1 students can read Latin right away with no problems." If that is you, go forth and prosper. However, I have students who STRUGGLE to read in English, let alone another language. I want these students to feel successful in reading Latin which is developmentally-appropriate in their Latin acquisition process.

I encourage you to check out Adam Giedd's Confidence Readers in Spanish. I began reading them in my quest to read novice-level Spanish. Along with Margarita Perez Garcia, both of these authors have a great understanding of what emerging/novice-level readers of Spanish need. They also are masters at creating compelling plots with limited vocabulary!

Many Latin teachers use novellas for Free Voluntary Reading (FVR), and this is to be applauded. Nation and Wang (2020) write, "The single most important way that a teacher could improve their language program would be to include extensive reading." A key feature of pleasure reading is that we tend to read materials which are BELOW our reading level. I always use the examples that People Magazine is written at an 8th grade reading level and that most newspaper articles are written at a 10th grade reading level. When we read for pleasure BELOW our frustration level of reading, our reading fluency will increase. (The converse is true: if we wish to increase our reading comprehension, we should read ABOVE our frustration level of reading. Yet, I would not suggest doing this with language learners - that will only raise the affective filter in students!). Therefore, even advanced readers of Latin will benefit from reading emerging/novice level Latin readings!  

And just so you do not think that I am not practicing what I say here, I have written about 8-10 drafts of emerging/novice-low, "Confidence Readers" in Latin for which I just need to get on the ball and start shopping around to novella publishers.

Keith

Tuesday, July 28, 2026

Dear Novice-Level Authors...

Dear Novice-Level Authors,

I am a novice-low/mid reader of Spanish (I am a Latin teacher who knows very little Spanish, so my reading is self-taught), and over the past few years, I have begun to read many of your novellas which are targeted for novice-level readers. First off, thank you so much for your novellas! As Krashen states:

"Our reading ability, our ability to write in an acceptable writing style, our spelling ability, vocabulary knowledge, and our ability to handle complex syntax is the result of reading."

"The ability to speak is the result of listening [and] the result of reading." 

But what I appreciate mostly is how you have written novellas with a true understanding of those actual linguistic supports which emerging novice-low/novice mid readers truly need.

  • I love that you shelter vocabulary with predictable sentence patterns. Those two concepts need to go hand-in hand. When I read your novellas, I loved that I was able to focus on a limited number of vocabulary words but that the predictability of the sentence patterns allowed me to focus on reading. As I continued reading those novellas, I noticed that my reading speed increased. And once I recognized your particular writing style, I loved reading other novice-low/mid novellas which you had written, because I knew your sentence pattern! Krashen refers to this as narrow reading and states that narrow reading actually is a great way to deliver comprehensible input: "Since each writer has favorite expressions and a distinctive style, and each topic has its own vocabulary and discourse, narrow reading provides built-in review." 
  • I love that each of your sentences only focused on one idea. I did not get lost in your sentences due to too much information!
  • I loved that while your sentences focused on one idea, you would then combine those sentences as a compound sentence to reinforce continued exposure to that vocabulary. Because I had already read them as individual sentences, a longer compound sentence did not seem too much language.
  • I love that while your novellas did have a glossary, I did not rely on it after the first few pages. The constant repetitions of those words reinforced those words which I had to look up to the point that I no longer needed the glossary.
  • I love that you wrote your story as individual sentences - one sentence per line. I recall seeing some novellas which were written as paragraphs, and I remember right away feeling overwhelmed by the sheer sight of it (even though it was very comprehensible Spanish). Now I know how my own novice-low/mid students must feel sometimes when seeing a paragraph of Latin, even if 100% comprehensible. Seeing each sentence as a line made the reading appear doable and lowered my affective filter.
  • I love that while you were using a limited amount of vocabulary, you still found a way to create compelling plots. Granted they probably did not have a major conflict with rising tension, major character development, a climax, and denouement/resolution which had a twist ending, they did not need all of that. Your plots kept my interest! 
  • I love that you made me feel successful as a novice-low/mid reader of Spanish!
Thank you for showing me how I want my own emerging novice-low/mid Latin readers to feel when reading something which I have written. You have served as great examples! I look forward to reading more of your novellas in the future.

Keith

P.S. Special shoutouts to Margarita Perez Garcia, Mira Canion, and Adam Giedd for your wonderful novellas!